The Social Media Staffing Dilemma
Social media demands consistent, high-quality content across multiple platforms—often 20-40 pieces per week. Whether you build an internal team or partner with an agency impacts your costs, creativity, and results.
This guide compares the real trade-offs to help you make the right decision for your brand and budget.
Cost & Capability Comparison
What you get at each investment level
In-House Social Team
A capable social media manager costs $60,000-$90,000/year in salary alone. Add benefits ($15K+), tools ($3K+), training, and management overhead. You get brand immersion but limited creative diversity.
Social Media Agency
Agencies charge $4,000-$8,000/month ($48K-$96K/year) and provide a full team: strategist, content creators, community manager, and analytics. More content, diverse perspectives, and platform expertise.
Content Production Comparison
Volume and variety differences
Creative Diversity
Agencies bring multiple creatives with different perspectives. In-house relies on one person's vision.
Platform Coverage
Agencies have specialists for each platform. One in-house person can't master all channels equally.
Trend Response
Agencies work across clients and spot trends faster. In-house teams may miss what's working elsewhere.
Making the Right Choice
Choose in-house when you have very specific brand requirements that need daily immersion, budget for a full team (not just one person), and enough volume to keep them fully utilized.
Choose an agency when you need diverse content at scale, expertise across multiple platforms, and flexibility to adjust investment as needs change. Most growing brands find agencies deliver better ROI until they reach the scale to justify 3+ full-time social hires.
The hybrid approach—one internal coordinator plus agency execution—often delivers the best of both worlds for mid-size brands.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an agency more expensive than hiring someone?
Agencies cost $48K-$96K/year, while a qualified social media manager costs $75K+ with benefits, tools, and training. For that same investment, agencies provide 3-5 specialists instead of one generalist.
Will an agency understand our brand?
Good agencies invest heavily in brand immersion during onboarding and maintain ongoing alignment through regular strategy sessions. They won't know your brand day-one, but they catch up quickly.
How much content can an agency produce?
Agencies typically produce 40-60 pieces of content monthly compared to 15-25 from a single in-house person. Volume depends on package, but agencies consistently outproduce solo hires.
Can we start in-house and switch later?
Yes, many brands evolve from in-house to agency (or vice versa) as needs change. The key is not getting locked into long contracts or infrastructure that's hard to unwind.
Boost your productivity today
Tell us about your project and get a free quote from our team.